Tuesday, October 21, 2014

Kanche aur Postcard directed by Ridham Janve

Miraj Entertainment Limited presents Kanche aur Postcard, a film by Ridham Janve
Produced by Madan Paliwal
Cinematography by Prahlad Gopakumar
Music by Samarth Janve
Art Direction by Saurabh Vyas
Production by Megh Joshi,  Mridul Joshi, Basim Abu

Language: Hindi
Starring: Pradhuman Singh Choudhary,
Co-starring: Mohd. Sahil, Yash Bhatnagar, Yug Bhatnagar
Sateesh Ashi, Usha Bhatnagar, Krishna Kate.

Kanche aur Postcard’ wins the best short film, the Rajasthan Award at the Jaipur International Film Festival.
Official Selection at 44th International Film Festival of India (IFFI)
Award winner at First Goa Short Film Festival, Panaji
Official Selection at 18th International Children’s Film Festival of India, Hyderabad.
The film was also selected for the Mumbai International Film Festival (MIFF) in the best short film award category.
Official Selection at Madurai Film Festival 2013.
The songs of Kanche Aur Postcard Movie have been composed by Samarth Janve with Music Label.

Kanche Aur Postcard

Every holiday Bipin comes to his Mamaji’s home. Mamaji lives with the elderly grandmother in a modest locality, a small three storey apartment. The first floor of the apartment is occupied by people of very modest means, but the top floors have people who are better educated, Mamaji himself is a lawyer.
The entrance to this apartment is through an open courtyard where every day a hectic game of marbles is played by a bunch of schoolboys, who Mamaji calls ruffians. The game is extremely entertaining as there is a running commentary which not only concentrates on the players themselves but also on every person who crosses the courtyard, even the cow tied at a corner is not spared. All hell breaks loose one day, the commentator goes wild when Mamaji crossing the courtyard steps directly into a cow dung pat.
Although Bipin longs with every fibre of his little heart to join in the hearty game of kanche, Mamaji just will not have it. No matter how much Bipin begs and pleads, asks his grandmother to intercede, Mamaji will not yield. Mamaji has decided that the ruffians are not ‘good’ enough company for Bipin. Mamaji feels Bipin should have ‘better’boys around him. What Bipin feels or wants is not Mamaji’s concern. So one Sunday he takes Bipin for a tennis lesson. Bipin hates it; he wants a game of Kanche.
As the holidays near their end, Bipin gets desperate, he just needs a bag of kanche, so when his grandmother sends him to buy postcards Bipin just cannot resist it, with the change he buys a handful of kanche and for a precious half hour Bipin owns a bit of heaven. Those colourful kanche, glass globules of every boy’s childhood, glass globules of happiness, of colour. Every little boy has fought for them, earned them, yearned for them, dreamt of them and slept clutching those little globules.

But stolen goods do not last for long……… even if it is a handful of glorious marbles.

Quoting the Director Ridham Janve ‘Through its innocence and simplicity, Kanche aur Postcard explores deeper themes of class, caste, control and acceptance. The film also reminds us of the often overlooked yet very essential differences of perception and understanding between children and adults’

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h24UqX0tW0U





Saturday, October 18, 2014

G for Gandhi directed by Renjith Murali

G for Gandhi
Directed by Renjith Murali                                           Screenplay: Renjith Murali
Camera : Charan C Raj and Sibi Saif                           Editing : Sandeep Ganesh
BGM : Aji Sarass                                                        Studio : Kalidasa Digital

      ‘Who is the Father of the Nation?’ screams the teacher
‘Rahul Gandhi?’ Asks the cheeky youngster, who imagines himself the smarty pants of the class. The kids look pleased; their bright colleague has scored once more.
       No, of course not, Teacher snorts at the thought of the pansy, Rahul Gandhi being the Father of the Nation, looks very irritated.
‘Sonia Gandhi?’ The same cheeky youngster who is growing bolder by the minute. So what? nothing lost.      Are you out of your mind? Teacher extremely irritated, wondering if she should clout cheeky youngster, remembers corporal punishment is a punishable offence.
And then a mousy girl with tight little plaits says mildly ‘Mohandas Karamchand Gandhi? The Father of the Nation?’
Teacher beams, all is not lost, ‘Yes, Yes, Sulekha, you are a clever girl.’
Sulekha sits down primly, all around her, students whispering, ‘teacher’s pet’
This could be a modern day scenario at any school, who knows who Mahatma Gandhi really was, what did he advocate, what were his principles.
Of course we all ‘see’ Gandhi , we all recognize the smiling, balding visage of the Father of the Nation’.  In fact we ‘see’ him every day when we buy anything, we exchange red currency notes, blue currency notes, green currency notes and on each and every note there is the smiling, bald visage of the Father of the Nation.
That is what Renjith Murali, the Director of G for Gandhi wants us to see, this extremely simple film shows how we ‘see’ Gandhi every single day. This beautiful short film, shows ‘hands’ exchanging currency notes, hands buying groceries, hands buying vegetables, hands at a chemist buying contraceptives, bride’s parents exchanging dowry, groom’s parents refusing the dowry, not enough,  bride’s parents adding a couple of lakhs, the groom and his family happy with the transaction. 
  And on every single note the smiling visage of Mohandas Karamchand Gandhi, The Father of the Nation.
What do we or our young people around us know of him, his values? We turn away from his values, his simplicity and see him much like Renjith Murali says ‘reduced to a face as seen on our currency notes’. Further quoting Renjith,  ‘The popular perception that Gandhi is confined only to currency notes in India is examined. While contemporary society unconsciously turns itself away from the Gandhiyan idealist it is hoped that the young India will turn towards Gandhi.’

G for Gandhi has won quite a number of Awards;
Winner of Gandhi Short Film Festival.
Special Cash Award from the Governor of Kerala.
Best Film Award for First Goa Short Film Festival.
Best Creative Concept Award for First Goa Short Film Festival.
Special jury award for Nizhalattam Short Film festival.
Participation in Chennai Women's International Festival
Participation in  Chavara short film festival.

See the short film for yourself: //www.youtube.com/user/wolverinerenju

Thursday, October 16, 2014

‘Alli Malarum Adhikaalai’ or ‘The Water Lily that blossoms early in the morning.’ Director Monish

The First Goa Short Film Festival was organised by Marathi Chitrapat Parivar from Pune and what an amazing array of movies there was, such a variety of topics touching virtually every subject of interest and relevance today, child rape, the ills and benefits of internet, loneliness, terrorism, education for girls, and many more. We were truly spoilt for choice.

‘Alli Malarum Adhikaalai’ or ‘The Water Lily that blossoms early in the morning.’
Director: Monish                                              Screenplay: Monish
Producer: Monish                                            Language: Tamil

This simple film turned out to be another prize winning entry.
Arun a young handsome newspaper delivery person goes about his rounds, carefree and happy with no thought beyond getting his newspapers delivered in perfect condition and on time. Things are just fine until one bright day just as he turns the corner he sees a beautiful college girl, wow he thinks and nudges his fellow worker, they both agree she is an Apsara sent from heaven to brighten his mornings. Arun follows her to the bus-stop. At this very same bus stop, an office goer, also struck by her beauty, vows to win her and marry her.
Suddenly there seems to be a stiff competition, although both the suitors are unaware of each other and sadly for the suitors the girl is absolutely unaware of both men.
Arun on his rounds accidentally bumps into the girl’s brother; this happy turn of events happens one morning when Arun delivering newspapers in the neighborhood sees his Apsara return home to pick up something she has forgotten, oh my God, this is the best piece of luck that could have happened to Arun. From then on Arun is there bright and early following the girl from a safe distance until he gets to her bus stop, a huge smile plastered on his face, and a devil-may-care attitude on his cycle. Life is really good. Meanwhile the suitor at the bus stop has his own plans. He will give the girl a gift and propose marriage. But fate can thwart the best laid plans...
The girl’s brother informs Arun, that he would no longer be requiring a newspaper as they are moving to Adyar a distant place.  Arun nearly falls off his bike; his heart turns cold no Apsara to brighten his mornings? But Arun is extremely resourceful, talks to his Boss, cajoles and pleads with him and after some time gets his paper route changed to Adyar, love and a pretty girl can move mountains. The suitor at the bus stop meanwhile, who has no insider knowledge that Arun has, armed with a bouquet as well as a gift waits for the ‘girl of his dreams’ to arrive at the bus stop, all set to propose but the girl has already moved on...Not being as resourceful as Arun, he is left at the bus stop....
Arun on the other hand, now at Adyar, follows his Apsara as usual, not making any move to talk to her at all, not infringing on her space or privacy. For as he says ‘I am but a newspaper delivery person’ and she a college girl, I am just happy to see her, everyday, my day goes better, I am a filled with a glow of happiness.
Such a lovely feeling you will agree....


Thursday, October 2, 2014

Shalya ..... Director Bipin Khedekar

The First Goa Short Film Festival was organised by Marathi Chitrapat Parivar from Pune and what an amazing array of movies there was, such a variety of topics touching virtually every subject of interest and relevance today, child rape, the ills and benefits of internet, loneliness, terrorism, education for girls, and many more. We were truly spoilt for choice.
Sadly I managed just one entry from Goa, ‘Shalya’ directed by Bipin Khedekar and missed the much acclaimed ‘Chedum’ directed by Sharon Mazarello.

Shalya
Director: Bipin Khedekar                                               Screenplay: Sarvesh Naik
Producer: Damodar Naik                                              Language: Malwani Konkani
Cast: Anil Raiker,
Rati Bhatikar,
Ramprasad Kelkar,
Saieesh Naik

What a strange and a haunting film Shalya is. In a beautiful verdant setting, a man stands atop a log, his head in a noose; the men around him wear pristine white dhotis. Without any warning the log is pulled away from under him and you give a shout of horror. The man falls to the ground dangling at the end of the rope, he has died and Shankar, the hangman has finished his work. One more day in the life of a hangman, he bathes in the river and makes his way home to his wife and son.
Although it is a just work for Shankar, and work is very difficult to come by in this hamlet, Shankar is beset with sorrow, with doubt, with fear for his soul. He pesters his wife with his dark thoughts. Do you know he tells her, I feel such sorrow, such pain when I do my job, do you think ‘they’ curse me? His wife full of sadness for her husband says, maybe, but you are doing your duty. I dream such terrible, terrible dreams. Shankar spends his days in agony, in despair, with no way out, times are hard. So ashamed is he of his work that he never tells his son about his duties but promises his wife, as soon as our son begins to earn, I will give up this terrible, terrible work. 
Four school boys return home from school and like all boys start flinging stones at some stone markers, aiming with more and more precision all the while chattering about their father’s jobs. Everyone has a father who works crushing stones, the hangman’s son says, my father works at crushing stones. At this all the boys look at him in utter surprise, your father a stone crusher? A pause and a boy says in a rush, your father hangs people for a living. The hangman’s son is livid with anger, he cannot believe it, his father a hangman, his kind father, his father who loves him dearly, who always brings him his favourite ladus, his father who urges him to do his homework, who laughs with him, his father a hangman. His confusion is complete, he is devastated. There is a fight. The boy returns home and angrily confronts his parents. Leaves home without even a second glance.
What a terribly sad life for Shankar and his wife. Shankar a broken man just drags his body through his day and his terrible job. Is it a punishment for all those lives he has robbed? No point in looking back, no point in agonising. It is over; he has paid the price for all those lives.

Eleven years later, a constable enters their humble hut and hugs his parents…..

This very unusual film is truly remarkable because it is a first attempt for the Antarang Club, winning an Award at the First Goa Short Film Festival came as no surprise to anyone. The young and extremely talented Director Bipin Khedekar’s immense energy drew the best from every actor even the veteran Anil Raiker. As for the young boys they were a bunch of chattering birds just raring to go. That Antarang Club will have many more movies is something that everyone knows and expects.

https://www.facebook.com/pages/Shalya/154793391296955

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=88B5He88D-4



Sunday, September 28, 2014

Finding Fanny, a movie directed by Homi Adajania

Everyone is talking about Fanny, come now, not that Fanny, although as we know everyone is interested in that Fanny, but I mean the Fanny in ‘Finding Fanny’. Reviews, counter reviews, are Goans being portrayed in the right spirit, are we being shown as losers, drunkards, loose women, I am filled with trepidation. Aw, come on now, let me see the movie and decide.
I am cynical, I look at the pectoral cross that Angie is wearing almost as large as the Pope’s, and look at that, Savio actually has a cross tattooed down the nape of his neck. And then in a flash, I am reminded of a young girl who has an entire rosary tattooed down her forearm, to my question ‘what if you do not like it, the tattoo, in the years to come’ she replied rather angrily, ‘it is the Rosary’ and here I had been thinking Anjelina Jolie. Which self respecting Catholic does not sport a rosary brought from Vailankanni around their necks. I sit back and enjoy the movie.
 Goans are portrayed just as they are, kind, funny, sad, quirky and most importantly full of joy, just another bunch of people.
Ferdie, the village postman opens his door to find his own letter posted to Stefanie Fernandes some thirty six years ago, lying on his mat undelivered. He lets out a shriek, his beloved Fanny, never got his letter, she never knew of his love for her. This opens a pool of emotions for Ferdie, what should he do? Should he do anything at all, should he just keep mum like he has done all these years? Lingering deep inside Ferdie, is a teensy bit of hope. What if?
As his despondency increases Angie comes to visit him, she has been a constant visitor these many years, in fact since the day her husband, Gabo, choked on the plastic figurine atop their wedding cake and died. Everyone thought it had been a heart attack, but no, the guy was so drunk when he shoved a generous chunk of wedding cake in his mouth, never realising that a plastic figurine was deeply embedded inside the cake. For a widow, a young widow, who never even had a wedding night; Angie always has a smile plastered onto her no expression wooden face. Angie, young and pretty just goes on through life, with that smile, no desire to move on.
She lives with her formidable mother-in-law, Rosie Eucaristica. Now Rosie Eucaristica is a widow too, her husband died at sea, or has he? She is the undisputed First Lady of the village, a buxom beauty, so full of curves and oh so full of charm, she too never re-married, although plenty of suitors came knocking on her door with bouquets of roses, one of them the renowned artist Dom Pedro Cleto Colaço. If there is one thing that Dom Pedro Cleto Colaço wants, is to capture Rosie Eucaristica on his canvas and maybe seduce her but his efforts so far, have been foiled by the village wimp of a priest, Father Francis.
After much deliberation and a couple of sleepless nights, Angie decides that Ferdie should go on a Finding-Fanny journey. That’s easy, where do they get a driver? And a car?
On one of her many, aimless walks around the village, Angie sees Savio, stretched under a decrepit pile of rust, a much faded sky blue car. Voilà, answer to all those myriad problems occupying her mind, here is another of her ex- suitors, Savio, who is rumoured to have a state-of-the-art  garage business in Mumbai. Why not make a pass at him; after all she has to know what really happens on a wedding night. As a successful garage owner he could put that pile of rust in working condition as well as be the driver when they are on their ‘Finding Fanny’ quest. Sadly for Angie, Savio is not very keen on this trip, in fact he is surly, bad tempered, much cajoling, after all who can resist a fresh, young face for long? Savio agrees to be the driver for the trip.
But the car belongs to the artist, Dom Pedro Cleto Colaço, once Dom Pedro Cleto Colaço realises that there is a possibility of having Rosie Eucaristica as his travelling companion he jumps at the idea of being a part of the trip to find Fanny. He is sure that he will be able to seduce her and paint her; you see he too has an agenda.
As expected the journey is long, so many experiences, such a lot of soul searching, forgiveness, fun and laughter and as the narrator says at the end, what was important was the Journey, you make the best of what comes your way, you realise that in the act of pining for something you miss  so much in life. Essentially, 'Finding Fanny' is about new beginnings, finding the best in everything as you make your way through life.   
And oh yes, ‘Finding Fanny’ has hardly anything to do with Goa and Goans, it could be set anywhere in the World. Goa just happens to have beautiful scenery and most importantly beautiful people.

However I do have a grouse, why did the Director, Homi Adajania, have to treat the cat so very badly, it really was not funny.
Directed by
Homi Adajania
Written by
Homi Adajania
Kersi Khambatta
Starring
Naseeruddin Shah
Arjun Kapoor
Deepika Padukone
Pankaj Kapur
Dimple Kapadia
Narrated by
Deepika Padukone
Music by
Mathias Duplessy
Sachin-Jigar
Cinematography
Anil Mehta

Monday, September 8, 2014

Lord Ganesha

When you think of the attributes of Lord Ganesha, also known as Vinayaka, you are filled with awe. He is the elephant-headed Hindu god of wisdom, literature, worldly success and peace. The Lord is invoked before any sort of venture, be it marriages, jobs, business deals, yes nothing is undertaken without the blessings of Lord Ganesha. It is he who decides between success and failure, and it is left to him to remove obstacles or create them if and when deemed necessary.
Ganapati is not only the God of Beginnings; he is the true God of Learning and Wisdom, as befits his elephant head. The better attributes of the elephant are that it lives long, forgets nothing and is brave, loyal, kind, strong and gentle. Ganesha represents the unity of the Small Being the rat, with the Great Being, the elephant. It is the blending of the microcosm with the macrocosm, of a drop of water with the vast ocean and of the individual soul with divinity. The vehicle of Ganesha is a rat or mouse. As rats generally succeed in gnawing their way through every obstruction, the rat symbolizes this god's nature of destroying every obstacle.
But what makes Ganesha lovable and everyone’s favourite are the beautiful legends woven around him.

Ganesha and Kubera

Kubera, the god of wealth, was very proud of his boundless fortune. He was terribly proud of his wondrous palace, of his garden filled with the sweet smell of a profusion of roses and jasmine, the jewels his wife wore were the envy of every goddess, and his cooks were renowned for the food that made everyone drool. Oh yes, Kubera felt he knew how to live, and to live well, he even went to the extent of looking down on Lord Shiva who lived a simple austere life in the open mountains.
Now Kubera was not happy just to be wealthy, he wanted the other Gods and Goddesses to see and admire his wealth. He organised lavish parties, he organized gorgeous dinners, and although the Gods and Goddesses were full of praise, Kubera was not happy, oh no! The more parties he gave the emptier he felt, until his beautiful wife trying out her latest necklace of emeralds and pearls said, 
‘Kuby dear, there is one way to jolt everyone, make you the talk of Kailash, let us throw a huge party, a lavish one, with flowers, fireworks, decorations, she breathed deeply, arching her deep black brows. And…. let us invite among other famous guests, the divine couple, Shiva and Pârvatî.’
Kubera was thunderstruck, ‘oh, oh oh’ he did a little jig, most wondrous idea’; he gave her a hug and dashed off to get ready to visit the divine couple, Shiva and Pârvatî. He entered Shiva and Pârvatî’s abode with deep reverence and such humility although his mind was churning feverishly, ‘What is wrong here, what is this place, is this the palace of the divine couple, Shiva and Pârvatî?  Such wasteland, brrrr the cold wind slicing through my body. Can Shiva not even provide a better home for his family....
Shiva and Pârvatî were having a nice chat sipping a warm cup of ginger tea when they were interrupted by Kubera.
‘Oh Kubera, good to see you but what brings you here?’
Kubera was lost for words. He had come in a rush. He could not possibly tell Shiva and Pârvatî that he wanted them to admire his house, his jewels, his garden or his food. In a burst he said 
'I wanted to invite you for a party’
‘Party?’ they both said, what’s the occasion?
Kubera was lost for words. He said ‘Nothing just that I am so blessed…’
In a flash, both Shiva and Pârvatî realised that there was no occasion, Kubera just wanted to show off.
Very politely, Pârvatî declined the invitation, ‘Kubera, thank you but we will not be able to come’
Then Pârvatî saw the despair in Kubera’s eyes, his desire to show off and she said ‘’But Ganesha our son would love to go, wouldn’t you like it Ganesh’
‘Oooh yes said little Ganesha, will there be sweets? He asked
‘You bet the best of sweets here in Kailash’ muttered Kubera
After a while a clean little Ganesha walked into Kubera’s sumptuous palace. Although Ganesha was well dressed, his red silk dhoti freshly pressed, his broad flat feet carried a trail of wet sticky mud which left prints all over the pristine marble floor. Kubera’s wife looked at her floor in utter disgust. Had Ganesha not been the son of Shiva and Pârvatî she would have pulled his broad ears and flung him out. He sniffed food and smiled broadly, ‘food he said, Ganesha loved food and sweets his mouth watered, his little trunk quivered in anticipation.
Very politely Kubera and his wife served him. Hardly had they turned their backs, Ganesha had finished a heaped thali of puris, vegetables, ghee rice, lentil curry, papads, pickles and a bowl of kheer. One happy little burp and little Ganesha said very politely ‘Oh that was lovely’ Kubera and his wife beamed broadly…. ‘But I am still hungry…’ Another huge thali, this time with additional helpings of modaks, kheer. Burp…  ‘ I am still hungry…’ large tears brimmed in little Ganesha’s deep brown eyes threatening to roll down his cheeks. More food. Little Ganesha still hungry, still unhappy. This went on for a long time, little Ganesha was still hungry, and very unhappy. Kubera and his wife screaming at the servants cook more, cook more. Servants running to the market, buying whatever was available, no way could they please little Ganesha. He was still hungry, and very unhappy.
Hasty consultation, Kubera and his wife, ‘What are we going to do?’ ‘He is unhappy’
‘And whose wonderful idea was it?’ asked Kubera sarcastically
‘And who was so happy, and rushed off to Shiva and Pârvatîs abode immediately’ retorted Kubera’s wife equally sarcastically.
But when they looked into their vast hall, there was Little Ganesha reclining on a mound of cushions, not resting happily as they thought he would after a huge meal, replete and satiated, but weeping silently, huge tears rolling down his plump cheeks, his trunk curled into a tight loop. Oh yes, Little Ganesha was truly an unhappy little God and he was their guest, they had invited him. Kubera rushed to Shiva and Pârvatî’s abode and entered meekly. There were Shiva and Pârvatî happily chatting and playing cards.
Kubera rushed to Shiva and Pârvatî and threw himself at their feet; Shiva bent down and picked him up. Shiva looked deep into Kubera’s eyes, no words were spoken, there was no need.  Kubera understood that it was his pride, his vanity, his desire to show off his beautiful house, his jewellery and his possessions that was at the root of Little Ganesha’s unhappiness. Kubera felt so small, so miserable, so unworthy. Pârvatî went inside and got a handful of roasted rice. Kubera realised that when he had served Little Ganesha a huge, sumptuous meal, he wanted to show off, there was no love, there was no desire to please a guest, there was only a desire to show-off his enormous wealth.
Humbly he took the handful of puffed rice and knelt down besides Little Ganesha and said full of sorrow and deep love and consideration, ‘Eat Little Ganesha, eat my honoured guest’
Ganesha opened his tear filled eyes, rubbed them, looked deep into Kubera’s eyes and popped the puffed rice in his mouth, savoured the rice, chewed it slowly, then he smiled at Kubera a huge radiant smile of love and tenderness patted his head his head with his curly trunk, ‘What a wonderful meal Kubera, truly a beautiful repast, thank you ever so much’
Little Ganesha got up slowly bowed to Kubera and his wife and happily bouncing his plump body and swinging his little trunk went home. 

http://hindumythologyforgennext.blogspot.in/2012/02/ganesha-and-kubera.html


Sunday, August 10, 2014

The Khmer Rouge trials; Justice late, better than never

The Khmer Rouge trials
Justice late, better than never
Aug 7th 2014, 13:34 by L.H. | PHNOM PENH

For Cambodians it has been a long wait. Almost 35 years after the Khmer Rouge were driven from power by a Vietnamese invasion, the movement’s last surviving senior leaders have been found guilty of crimes against humanity and sentenced to jail for life.
Or whatever is left of their lives. Nuon Chea, chief ideologue for the Khmer Rouge and “Brother No. 2” after Pol Pot, is 88 years old. Khieu Samphan, once the head of state in Democratic Kampuchea as the country had been renamed, is 83. When they were taken away from the purpose-built courthouse on August 7th, a palpable sense of relief descended on the room.
Hundreds of Cambodians had been brought from far and wide to pack the public gallery for the historic decision. Many of them hugged, smiled and bowed in a show of respect to the tribunal that saw the case through, the Extraordinary Chambers in the Courts of Cambodia (ECCC). Bou Meng, a survivor of the S-21 torture and extermination camp, smiled broadly and expressed his approval simply: “good, good”.
In passing their final sentence, the judge Nil Nonn said that these two leaders had stripped Cambodians of their fundamental rights in the course of perpetrating a joint criminal enterprise to “suppress and subjugate the human population”. They were found guilty of conducting a systematic attack on civilians.
“The attack took many forms, including forced transfer, murder, extermination, enforced disappearances, attacks against human dignity and political persecution,” Mr Nil Nonn said. “This attack victimised millions of Cambodians.” He cited one testimony according to which witnesses saw “a Khmer Rouge soldier tear apart a crying baby who was crawling on his dead mother's body.”
As many as 2.2m people perished between April 1975 and January 1979. At that point the Vietnamese-led Communist takeover marked the end of one civil conflict but also the beginning of another, as Pol Pot led his loyalists into the jungle to fight a rearguard war against the new regime in the capital.
While the Khmer Rouge were still in Phnom Penh, the institution of money itself was abolished—along with all semblances of traditional Khmer life—as the cities and towns were emptied and millions of civilians forced into the remote countryside. There they were worked under wretched conditions, desperately lacking food, water and medicine.
In a way, there were too many crimes with which Nuon Chea, Khieu Samphan and many of their cohorts should have been charged. The fraction of their guilt that was decided in this hearing, Case 002/01 it is called, focused on the forced evacuation of Phnom Penh, the forced movement of people up until late 1977 and the persecution of former soldiers, civil servants and their families from the regime of Lon Nol, the American-backed nationalist who preceded them.
Nuon Chea wore his characteristic grimace and black sunglasses and remained seated in his wheelchair. Khieu Samphan stood as their verdicts and sentences were read. Neither man flinched.
Both had insisted they were innocent of the specific charges against them. At its heart their justification was that the evacuation of Phnom Penh had been deemed necessary to save the Cambodian people; they had reason to believe that the Americans were intending to bomb the capital. Mr Nil Nonn said the bench of international and Cambodian justices had decided their defence deserved no credence.
Nuon Chea had also claimed evidence used against him was “littered with doubts and full of lies”, in particular the testimony given by Kaing Guek Eav. “Duch”, as he is also known, is already serving a life sentence, for the role he played in killing thousands of detainees processed under his command at a prison complex called S-21.
Khieu Samphan’s judgment was less severe. The court found that he had never held sufficient authority to issue orders to commit the crimes in question. He had however “justified, defended and praised the common purpose and policies” of the Khmer Rouge that resulted in the atrocities.
The ECCC, which is backed by the UN, has been criticised sharply during its nine years in operation. Its critics fault it for lengthy delays; its susceptibility to interference by Cambodia’s current prime minister, Hun Sen; and for kickbacks to local staff, when it was being established.
It has also been costly. More than $200m has been spent on its proceedings already. The tribunal’s supporters justify the high cost by arguing that the total sum works out to equal about $100 for each person who died under the reign of the Khmer Rouge. It makes for a macabre accounting of the ultra-Maoists’ dream of moulding Cambodia into an agrarian utopia.
Youk Chhang is the executive director of an NGO called the Documentation Centre of Cambodia, which has been dedicated to collecting evidence from the Khmer Rouge period that could be used in a prosecution. He is among those who thinks that the court’s search for justice was better late than never, even if its legal processes were flawed.
Its accomplishment is more significant, Mr Youk Chhang says, in light of the fact that the world has done so little to change its ways in the decades since the Cambodian nightmare. Indeed, in his view “since the UN signed the Genocide Convention in 1948, not one genocide has been prevented. A court of law is only established after millions have already died. We need to search for a means to prevent such crimes from happening again,” he said.
Nuon Chea and Khieu Samphan know now where they will be spending the rest of their days, as they did long before this verdict. Whether this will be their final conviction is another question. Both men are facing additional charges of genocide in Case 002/02; it was launched last week and is expected to take another two years.